Oral storytelling: a lost art in American culture

Oral storytelling: a lost art in American culture
Mustafa K. Mumtaz is a junior history and data journalism double major. Photo by Elsa Friesen.

My history teacher was casually ranting about the state of the country to one of my classmates when another student caught his attention by talking a little too rambunctiously. He attacked him with his trusty steel ruler, which had several dents from years of use.

It’s safe to say students learned little to no history in this class, but I frequently got to hear fascinating stories from both my peers and our teacher. 

I come from the Punjab in Pakistan, a region known for its art of “qissakhwani,” or storytelling. The masterful use of exaggeration, tangents and questioning mixed with suspense is part of the average conversation at home. 

In my three years in the U.S., I have come to appreciate the efficiency of American communication, but the pomp and formality of conversations back home have their own charm. 

In that world history class, students came when they felt like it. One of these characters made an appearance after a few months of hiatus with a large bandage wrapping around his head and an arm in a sling. 

Seeing his condition, our teacher immediately lost interest in teaching and began interrogating the student as to the cause of his injury. He had received previous intel from another class that the student had been involved in a group altercation.

The student told his tale piece by piece: A feature of storytelling I miss greatly in American conversation.

Like any good story, he began by setting the scene. Naturally, this was a parking lot behind a bougie coffee shop. Many questions were thrown at the storyteller: “Which coffee shop was it?”, “Was so-and-so there?”, and most importantly, “Why do you all like this coffee shop?” 

These questions did not receive short, one-word answers; they were greatly expanded upon, and many narrative liberties were taken.

These seemingly irrelevant questions were what made the story interesting. “So-and-so” was present at the event, much to the amusement of those in the class. The son of an important dignitary, he walked around with an elevated sense of grandeur. But at the alleged altercation he stood off to the side by his car and took turns flipping the bird on both fingers with his sidekick.

While I’m sure he did not spend 15 whole minutes repeating these actions, the image of him doing so created a wave of laughter throughout our class. Stretching the truth by exaggerating to elevate a story is a necessary part of oral storytelling.

Of course, overexaggerating reduces its effect, which is why, when the story reached the boring part — the fight itself — our storyteller used frequent pauses to make it interesting. 

First, the storyteller introduced an unknown student and the security guard, known as “The Pole” who accompanied him at the event. As the guard couldn’t join in on an assault of adolescents, he pulled a pipe out of a nearby wall and beat down an innocent dessert seller on the side of the road. 

With each sentence the storyteller  would pause, amping up the ridiculousness of the story to make the unfortunate scenario even more hilarious.

You can’t tell a good story without building suspense. In the U.S., I see people make the mistake of dropping bombastic statements in sentences, but they don’t receive any questions from the audience to expand on the idea or any time to build up to the punchline.

For example, I was recently hanging out with a group of my American friends when one brought up that a professor of mine nearly died in class. The statement was delivered like a bomb, but no follow-up came. Listeners didn’t ask what a side character thought about this event, or what the professor was wearing, or what was happening to the table in the background.

I think this occurs due to a lack of silence in conversations. People are thinking about what they want to say in response instead of actually listening to what the other person is saying. Not only does this make it impossible to gain anything from a conversation, but it also kills any interest the listener has in the story. 

I have learned that my domestic peers don’t like to pause between sentences.

Unfortunately, I never learned how the student in my world history class really got his injuries. He claimed that he broke his hand suckerpunching an opponent and then fell afterwards, explaining the head injury. But the story was so beautifully told that I didn’t care what happened to him or how much of it was true. 

Regardless of subject matter, active listening and colorful storytelling can make any conversation a cinematic experience.