Make senate votes public: Bring back transparency in student government

Make senate votes public: Bring back transparency in student government
Xavier McKenzie is a sophomore journalism, Spanish and international studies triple major. Photo by Elsa Friesen.

Last spring, when students were campaigning for positions on the Augustana Student Association (ASA), transparency was a common talking point between newcomers and incumbents alike. Yet for years, ASA has failed to provide students with the most basic information to hold senators accountable: how they vote. 

If ASA truly cares about transparency the single most effective reform would be publishing how each senator votes. 

ASA is currently improving its website, which is the perfect opportunity to begin integrating vote breakdowns online.

We should think of Augustana like a country instead of a university. As students who pay tuition, we are essentially tax payers. While most of our money goes to the university’s administration, which acts as our executive branch, we also pay an activities fee to ASA, which acts as our legislative branch.

In the United States, recording and publishing congressional meetings has been a historical precedent. The Constitution states that both the House of Representatives and the Senate are required to routinely keep and publish a journal of their proceedings.

For whatever reason, ASA did not include this provision in their constitution.

Without knowing how a senator votes, it is impossible to both hold senators accountable and make informed decisions at the ballot box.

Every year we voice our concerns to ASA by voting in elections and deciding which senators we want to represent us. 

Within the current system, it can be hard for students to know when to hold those representatives accountable because our knowledge of a senators’ legislative history is limited.

Although students can view meeting minutes on the website, we can only see a senator’s stance on a given proposal when they choose to speak up about it — which happens a lot less than when they vote on proposals. 

When senators vote, they are supposed to represent the larger student body who voted for them. If we don’t feel like they are accurately reflecting the will of us students, then we should vote them out of office.

Currently, a senator could say they are a proponent of something publicly but vote against it privately, and students would be none the wiser. All students have to go on is trust.

Publicizing senators’ votes would change that dynamic. 

A senator’s vote should serve as a public expression of how they feel about an issue. Transparency motivates senators to seek out student opinions and take into account multiple perspectives on campus when making decisions. This forces senators to be more educated about what they’re voting on.

By viewing a senator’s voting history, a student is able to make a more accurate judgement about whether that senator should be holding office come reelection.

Some might argue that private voting allows senators to vote using their best judgement without fearing backlash if they vote based on a personal conviction rather than bending to whatever position is most popular.

It’s important to recognize, however, that accountability and independence aren’t mutually exclusive. A senator should vote in the way they feel is right, but if they are voting on behalf of students, then students should still be allowed to see that decision.

ASA President Igen Nyawanda stated that there is a precedent not to publicly broadcast how each senator votes. Just because disclosing voting information wasn’t a part of ASA history does not mean it can’t be a part of its future.

The best way to establish publishing senators’ voting history as a permanent fixture is through a constitutional amendment. Proposing a constitutional amendment requires securing signatures from 5% of current senators. Passing the amendment would then require a two-thirds majority.

If senators truly want to improve ASA transparency, this is the most effective measure they can implement. Our representatives should be willing to stand by their decisions.